Health diplomacy the adaptation of global health interventions to local needs in sub-Saharan Africa and Thailand: evaluating findings from Project Accept (HPTN 043)
: BMC Public Health OUTPUT TYPE
: Journal Article
: S.Kevany, G.Khumalo-Sakutukwa, O.Murima, A.Chingono, P.Modiba, G.Gray, H.Van Rooyen
, K.Mrumbi, J.Mbwambo, S.Kawichai, S.Chariyalertsak, C.Chariyalertsak, E.Paradza, M.Mulawa, K.Curran, K.Fritz, S.F.MorinKEYWORDS
, PROJECT ACCEPTDEPARTMENT
: Human and Social Capabilities (HSC)
: HSRC Library: shelf number 7568
If you would like to obtain a copy of this Research Output, please contact Hanlie Baudin at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Background: Study-based global health interventions, especially those that are conducted on an international or multi-site basis, frequently require site-specific adaptations in order to (1) respond to socio-cultural differences in risk determinants, (2) to make interventions more relevant to target population needs, and (3) in recognition of 'global health diplomacy' issues. We report on the adaptations development, approval and implementation process from the Project Accept voluntary counseling and testing, community mobilization and post-test support services intervention.
Methods: We reviewed all relevant documentation collected during the study intervention period (e.g. monthly progress reports; bi-annual steering committee presentations) and conducted a series of semi-structured interviews with project directors and between 12 and 23 field staff at each study site in South Africa, Zimbabwe, Thailand and Tanzania during 2009. Respondents were asked to describe (1) the adaptations development and approval process and (2) the most successful site-specific adaptations from the perspective of facilitating intervention implementation.
Results: Across sites, proposed adaptations were identified by field staff and submitted to project directors for review on a formally planned basis. The cross-site intervention sub-committee then ensured fidelity to the study protocol before approval. Successfully-implemented adaptations included: intervention delivery adaptations (e.g. development of tailored counseling messages for immigrant labour groups in South Africa) political, environmental and infrastructural adaptations (e.g. use of local community centers as VCT venues in Zimbabwe); religious adaptations (e.g. dividing clients by gender in Muslim areas of Tanzania); economic adaptations (e.g. co-provision of income generating skills classes in Zimbabwe); epidemiological adaptations (e.g. provision of 'youth-friendly' services in South Africa, Zimbabwe and Tanzania), and social adaptations (e.g. modification of terminology to local dialects in Thailand: and adjustment of service delivery schedules to suit seasonal and daily work schedules across sites).
Conclusions: Adaptation selection, development and approval during multi-site global health research studies should be a planned process that maintains fidelity to the study protocol. The successful implementation of appropriate site-specific adaptations may have important implications for intervention implementation, from both a service uptake and a global health diplomacy perspective.
Related Research Outputs:
- Nelson Mandela/HSRC study of HIV/AIDS: South African national HIV prevalence, behavioural risks and mass media: household survey 2002
- HIV/AIDS in South Africa: entitlement and rights to health-implications of the 2002 household survey
- HIV/AIDS in Southern Africa: executive summary
- WHO: global initiative on primary prevention of substance abuse: community profile 1 and 2 of South Africa
- Social impact assessment of development projects
- Book review: Bradby, H. & Hundt, G.L. (eds). 2010. Global perspectives on war, gender and health: the sociology and anthropology of suffering. Surrey: Ashgate Publishing. 157 p. ISBN 9780754675235
- The forgotten fifty percent: a review of sexual and reproductive health research and programs focused on boys and young men in Sub-Saharan Africa
- Facts, fiction and fabrication: service delivery in South Africa: 1994-1999
- South African public health system and prevention of communicable diseases
- The impact of HIV/AIDS on land rights: case studies from Kenya
- Monitoring alcohol and drug abuse trends in South Africa (July 1996-December 2002), Phase 13
- Child development, parasites and public policy
- Report on colloquium on improving the health of school age children in an era of HIV/AIDS: linking policies, programmes & strategies for the 21st century
- Development, health and the environment: factors influencing infant and child survival in South Africa
- Body image and physical activity among black university students in South Africa
- Health care-seeking behaviour for child illnesses among rural mothers in South Africa: a pilot study
- Black South African children's understanding of health and illness: colds, chicken pox, broken arms and AIDS
- Health actions and health promotion among a sample of rural black South African children
- Water services and public health: the 2000-01 cholera outbreak in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa
- Education and health facilities (including HIV/AIDS and gender)